Is Blue Topaz Or Aquamarine More Valuable?

Is Blue Topaz Or Aquamarine More Valuable?

Blue topaz and aquamarine are cherished for their stunning blue hues, each captivating in its unique way. However, when it comes to value, these gemstones can vary significantly. Join us as we delve into an in-depth comparison to uncover the factors that determine which of these beautiful stones might hold more value.

Understanding Blue Topaz and Aquamarine

Blue Topaz

Blue topaz is a variety of the mineral topaz that has been treated to enhance its blue color. Naturally occurring blue topaz is rare, so most blue topaz on the market has been irradiated and heat-treated to achieve its vivid blue shades.


Aquamarine is a member of the beryl family, which also includes emeralds. This gemstone is prized for its pale blue to blue-green color, reminiscent of the sea. Unlike blue topaz, aquamarine's color is natural, often requiring no additional treatments.

Factors Affecting Value


  1. Blue Topaz: The value of blue topaz is influenced by its color intensity. The three primary shades of blue topaz are Sky Blue, Swiss Blue, and London Blue. London Blue is the darkest and generally the most valuable, followed by Swiss Blue and Sky Blue.
  2. Aquamarine: Aquamarine’s value is also largely determined by its color. The most prized aquamarines are those with a deep, vibrant blue. Stones with a pale or greenish hue are generally less valuable.


  1. Blue Topaz: Typically, blue topaz is found with excellent clarity and minimal inclusions, which can make even large stones relatively affordable.
  2. Aquamarine: Aquamarine is also known for its high clarity, often being eye-clean with few inclusions. Stones with high clarity are more desirable and valuable.


  1. Blue Topaz: The cut of blue topaz can significantly affect its value. Well-cut stones that maximize brilliance and color are more sought after.
  2. Aquamarine: Similarly, the cut of aquamarine impacts its value. Expertly cut aquamarines that enhance the stone’s natural color and clarity can fetch higher prices.

Carat Weight

  1. Blue Topaz: Larger blue topaz stones are readily available and do not increase significantly in price per carat compared to smaller stones.
  2. Aquamarine: Larger aquamarine stones are rarer and can increase significantly in price per carat. High-quality large aquamarines are particularly valuable.

Market Demand and Rarity

Blue Topaz

While blue topaz is popular and widely available, its market price remains relatively low due to the abundance of treated stones. The gemstone’s affordability and vibrant color make it a popular choice for fashion jewelry, but its value does not appreciate significantly over time.


Aquamarine, on the other hand, is less abundant and more valued by collectors and gemstone enthusiasts. Its natural color and association with high-quality beryl add to its appeal and market value. Aquamarine jewelry often holds its value well and can be considered a more significant investment.

Historical and Cultural Significance

Blue Topaz

Historically, topaz has been associated with healing and protective properties. Blue topaz, in particular, is thought to enhance communication and clarity of thought. However, these associations do not significantly impact its market value.


Aquamarine has a rich history and cultural significance. It was believed to be the treasure of mermaids and was used by sailors as a talisman of good luck, fearlessness, and protection. The historical significance and lore surrounding aquamarine can enhance its desirability and value.

Popular Uses in Jewelry

Blue Topaz

Blue topaz is commonly used in a variety of jewelry pieces, from rings and earrings to pendants and bracelets. Its affordability and availability in large sizes make it ideal for statement pieces. Blue topaz is often set in silver or white gold to complement its cool blue tones.


Aquamarine is frequently used in high-end jewelry. Its elegant blue hue pairs beautifully with both white and yellow metals, making it versatile for different designs. Aquamarine is often featured in engagement rings, fine necklaces, and heirloom pieces, reflecting its higher value and desirability.

Investment Potential

Blue Topaz

Due to its widespread availability and treatment processes, blue topaz is not typically considered a high-value investment gemstone. Its value remains relatively stable, but it does not appreciate significantly over time.


Aquamarine, particularly high-quality stones, can be a good investment. Its rarity, natural color, and demand in the gemstone market contribute to its value appreciation over time. Collectors and enthusiasts often seek out fine aquamarine pieces for their beauty and investment potential.


While both blue topaz and aquamarine are beautiful gemstones, aquamarine generally holds more value due to its natural color, rarity, and historical significance. Blue topaz, with its vibrant color and affordability, remains a popular choice for fashion jewelry but does not command the same market value as aquamarine.

At Caleesi Designs, we offer a stunning selection of both blue topaz and aquamarine pieces, each crafted with the utmost attention to detail and artistry. Whether you're drawn to the deep blues of aquamarine or the bright hues of blue topaz, our expert team can help you find the perfect piece to suit your style and needs.

We look forward to helping you find a piece that tells your unique story. For the latest updates and to see our beautiful jewelry, follow us on Instagram. Experience the artistry and personal touch at Caleesi Designs, where every piece tells a story.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.